News

Samsung, Micron, and SK hynix face class-action antitrust lawsuit over artificial DRAM shortage

The global memory market is facing a legal reckoning as a U.S. federal judge has cleared the way for a massive antitrust lawsuit against the industry's three dominant players. The ruling ensures that Samsung, Micron, and SK hynix must answer allegations that they colluded to create an artificial DRAM shortage to inflate profits.

This legal hurdle comes after U.S. District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied a joint motion to dismiss the case on November 14. The lawsuit, originally filed on June 25, 2026, by a group of 17 consumers and small businesses, alleges that these three companies violated Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The plaintiffs argue that the trio, which collectively controlled more than 91 percent of global DRAM revenue as of the third quarter of 2025, engaged in a coordinated effort to restrict supply.

The Mechanics of the Shortage

Central to the case is the allegation that the manufacturers intentionally throttled the production of conventional memory to pivot toward the high-margin AI sector. According to the complaint, the companies began cutting conventional memory production in late 2022 and redirected wafer capacity toward High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) in 2023. This shift was particularly impactful because HBM requires three to four times more silicon wafer area per gigabyte than standard DDR5 memory. The result was a severe tightening of the supply for PCs and consumer electronics, which allegedly drove conventional DRAM prices up by as much as 697 percent over an 18-month window.

The defendants argued that these moves were not collusive but were instead reactionary responses to the booming demand for AI technology. They further contended that their actions mirrored a previous antitrust lawsuit from 2018 that was ultimately dismissed. Judge Wise, however, rejected this defense. In her ruling, she noted that while competitors in concentrated markets naturally monitor one another, the allegations in this case suggested something more coordinated. She described the behavior not as "hawks watching each other," but as "hawks flying in formation," an activity she noted is not ordinary for such competitors.

Beyond the shift to HBM, the court identified several other parallel actions that pointed toward prior coordination. These included the simultaneous winding down of DDR4 production in the same quarter of 2025 and the refusal of Samsung and SK hynix to enter into long-term contracts (LTAs) with major conventional DRAM buyers. The evidence also points to Micron’s December 3, 2025, announcement that it would shut down its 30-year-old consumer memory brand, Crucial, and the adoption of nearly identical customer-vetting practices by all three firms in January 2026.

Legal Precedent and Next Steps

This pattern of behavior is not without precedent, as the court noted the companies' history of price-fixing between 1998 and 2002. While the current ruling does not establish final wrongdoing, the judge found the allegations sufficient to support a plausible inference of collusion. Consequently, Samsung, Micron, and SK hynix have been ordered to file formal answers to the complaint by December 7, 2026, with an initial case management conference scheduled for January 12, 2027.

The progression of this lawsuit carries significant implications for the semiconductor industry, as the discovery process may force the three memory makers to surrender internal emails, management records, and documents regarding capacity investment and customer allocation. Such transparency could expose the internal logic behind production cuts and HBM prioritization. Furthermore, a successful suit could shift the balance of power back toward PC, smartphone, and server manufacturers, providing them with more leverage to demand long-term supply commitments and more stable pricing structures.